Cambridge IELTS 3, Test 3, Reading Passage 2

    Amazonia: reading answers and analysis

    In 1942 Allan Holmberg described the Siriono as among the most backward people on Earth, and that image shaped the belief that the Amazon forest can't support complex societies. The writer says archaeology proves otherwise: large, advanced societies thrived for over a thousand years before Europeans arrived. Ignoring people's role has hurt both the forest and its Indians.

    Questions 13-25 · 13 marks · 3 question blocks

    Answer key and self-check

    Type what you wrote and hit mark. Hide the key first if you haven't done the passage yet. Every question number jumps to its explanation.

    QYour answerAnswer
    Questions 13-15 · Matching headings (i-vii)
    13
    v
    14
    i
    15
    vi
    Questions 16-21 · YES / NO / NOT GIVEN
    16
    NO
    17
    YES
    18
    NOT GIVEN
    19
    NO
    20
    YES
    21
    YES
    Questions 22-25 · Multiple choice
    22
    C
    23
    A
    24
    B
    25
    C

    Where the answers sit

    The headings (13-15) cover A, B and D (C is the example). YES / NO / NOT GIVEN (16-21) runs from B to F. The multiple choice (22-25) goes back to A and moves forward to F.

    Matching headings (i-vii)

    Questions 13-15

    How to attack this block: A is Holmberg's early fieldwork among the Siriono, and B is the popular belief that the Amazon can't support complex societies. D says the region's natural history is tied to what its prehistoric people did. The technology heading and the hostility heading describe nothing in the passage.

    Question 13

    Answer: vSection A, first sentence

    Which heading fits Section A?

    In 1942 Allan R Holmberg, a doctoral student in anthropology from Yale University, USA, ventured deep into the jungle of Bolivian Amazonia and searched out an isolated band of Siriono Indians.

    Question says → Passage says

    • early researchIn 1942… a doctoral student in anthropology
    • among the Indian Amazonsan isolated band of Siriono Indians

    Why: A is a report of Holmberg's 1942 fieldwork: what he found about the Siriono's villages, food and tools. Research from 1942 is 'early' compared with the 'recent' evidence the writer brings in later.

    The trap: ii (The role of recent technology in ecological research) picks up the talk of technology in A. But that's the Siriono's tools, not technology used in research, and nothing in A is recent.

    Question 14

    Answer: iSection B, fourth sentence

    Which heading fits Section B?

    living proof that Amazonia could not - and cannot - sustain a more complex society

    Question says → Passage says

    • unable to sustain complex societiescould not - and cannot - sustain a more complex society

    Why: B describes the popular belief: the forest is hostile to civilisation, Indian simplicity is an adaptation to it, and ruins of complex cultures must belong to outsiders. All of it adds up to the idea that Amazonia can't support complex societies.

    The trap: iii (hostility of the indigenous population) borrows 'hostile' from B, but B calls the forest 'hostile to human civilization'. The people aren't hostile, and North America has nothing to do with it.

    Question 15

    Answer: viSection D, last sentence

    Which heading fits Section D?

    The archaeological evidence shows that the natural history of Amazonia is to a surprising extent tied to the activities of its prehistoric inhabitants.

    Question says → Passage says

    • the influence of prehistoric inhabitantstied to the activities of its prehistoric inhabitants
    • Amazonian natural historythe natural history of Amazonia

    Why: D says ecologists were wrong to leave people out, and its last sentence gives the main point: Amazonia's natural history is closely linked to what its prehistoric people did. The heading matches it almost word for word.

    The trap: iv (Recent evidence) fits the first line, 'The evidence for a revised view', but it's already used as the example for C. And D is about what that evidence shows, the human influence on nature.

    YES / NO / NOT GIVEN

    Questions 16-21

    How to attack this block: The writer calls the 'Amazonia can't support complexity' idea a myth (NO) and a costly misconception (YES). Ecologists wrongly assumed that nature alone shaped the forest (NO). The Indians are crucial to the forest (YES), and parts of it could support more people (YES). No other ecosystems are compared.

    Question 16

    Answer: NOSection C, second and fifth sentences

    Does the writer think Indians live simply because Amazonia could never support a more complex society?

    If the lives of Indians today seem "primitive", the appearance is not the result of some environmental adaptation or ecological barrier

    Question says → Passage says

    • the reason for the simplicitythe appearance is not the result of
    • always been unable to support a more complex societyan extensive network of complex societies… thrived there for more than 1,000 years

    Why: This is the popular view from B, and C rejects it: complex societies thrived in Amazonia for over 1,000 years, and today's simple lifestyle comes from centuries of economic and political pressure. The writer disagrees: NO.

    The trap: The statement is almost a copy of B's sentence ('living proof that Amazonia could not… sustain a more complex society'). B reports what other people believe. The writer's own view comes in C, where he calls it a myth.

    Question 17

    Answer: YESSection C, first two sentences

    Does the writer think there's an important mistaken popular belief about Amazonia's human history?

    The popular conception of Amazonia and its native residents would be enormously consequential if it were true. But the human history of Amazonia in the past 11,000 years betrays that view as myth.

    Question says → Passage says

    • a popular misconceptionThe popular conception… that view as myth
    • the human history of Amazoniathe human history of Amazonia

    Why: The writer calls the popular conception a 'myth', which makes it a misconception, and Sections E and F show how much damage it has done to the forest and the Indians. That's why it's 'crucial'. YES.

    The trap: 'Would be enormously consequential if it were true' can confuse you into thinking the writer says the idea isn't important. He's saying it would matter hugely if true, and then shows it isn't true.

    Question 18

    Answer: NOT GIVENSection D, second sentence

    Does the writer say we can learn from similar ecosystems elsewhere?

    Ecologists have assumed that tropical ecosystems were shaped entirely by natural forces

    Question says → Passage says

    • similar ecosystemstropical ecosystems

    Why: Tropical ecosystems are mentioned only as something ecologists made wrong assumptions about. The writer never compares Amazonia with any other part of the world or suggests lessons from one. NOT GIVEN.

    The trap: The Rio meeting in E brought together leaders 'from across the world', which sounds international. But it was about how developing countries can grow without destroying resources, not about lessons from other ecosystems.

    Question 19

    Answer: NOSection D, second sentence

    Did most ecologists know their study areas had been shaped by people?

    Ecologists have assumed that tropical ecosystems were shaped entirely by natural forces and they have focused their research on habitats they believe have escaped human influence.

    Question says → Passage says

    • were aware… shaped by human settlementassumed… shaped entirely by natural forces / habitats they believe have escaped human influence

    Why: Ecologists believed the opposite: that the forest was shaped only by nature and that their study areas had escaped human influence. So they weren't aware of human settlement's role. NO.

    The trap: Feinsinger is an ecologist and says leaving people out is 'no longer tenable', which might make you think ecologists knew. He's one voice saying the old approach was wrong, which confirms most ecologists didn't know.

    Question 20

    Answer: YESSection F, second sentence

    Does the writer say the Indians are needed for the forest to stay healthy?

    the Indians, whose presence is in fact crucial to the survival of the forest, have suffered the most

    Question says → Passage says

    • necessary tocrucial to
    • the well-being of the forestthe survival of the forest

    Why: 'Crucial to the survival' is a stronger way of saying 'necessary to the well-being'. The writer states it directly: YES.

    The trap: The sentence before says their hunting and slash-and-burn farming 'often have been represented as harmful to the habitat'. That's how others have represented them. The writer's 'in fact' corrects it.

    Question 21

    Answer: YESSection F, fourth sentence

    Could some parts of Amazonia support more people?

    Archaeology makes clear that with judicious management selected parts of the region could support more people than anyone thought before.

    Question says → Passage says

    • certain parts of Amazoniaselected parts of the region
    • support a higher populationcould support more people

    Why: 'Selected parts' becomes 'certain parts', and 'more people' becomes 'a higher population'. A direct paraphrase: YES.

    The trap: Don't let 'with judicious management' push you to NOT GIVEN. The statement says 'would be possible', and a condition like careful management doesn't change that.

    Multiple choice

    Questions 22-25

    How to attack this block: Holmberg saw the Siriono as extremely primitive. The writer says ruins of complex societies are indigenous, not invaders'. The belief that only natural forces shaped the forest has been shown wrong. The new understanding points to a middle ground that should change development policy.

    Question 22

    Answer: CSection A, second sentence and second-last sentence

    What did Holmberg conclude about the Siriono in 1942?

    The Siriono, Holmberg later wrote, led a "strikingly backward" existence.

    Question says → Passage says

    • an extremely primitive society"strikingly backward" / among the most handicapped peoples of the world

    Why: 'Strikingly backward' and 'among the most handicapped peoples of the world' both say the Siriono were extremely primitive: C.

    The trap: D is the opposite of A: when food ran out, 'the tribe moved on', so they weren't settling permanently. B mixes in the idea of invaders from Section B, which is about ruins, not the Siriono.

    Question 23

    Answer: ASection C, third sentence

    What does the writer think the remains of complex societies prove?

    the region has supported a series of indigenous cultures for eleven thousand years; an extensive network of complex societies

    Question says → Passage says

    • evidence of early indigenous communitiesa series of indigenous cultures for eleven thousand years
    • recent discoveriesEvidence gathered in recent years

    Why: The writer uses the new evidence to show that complex indigenous societies thrived for over 1,000 years before Europeans arrived. So the remains belong to early indigenous communities: A.

    The trap: B (settlements by invaders) is the old view from B ('dismissed as the ruins of invaders'). The writer rejects it. C is also wrong, because the societies thrived 'before the arrival of Europeans'.

    Question 24

    Answer: BSection D, second and last sentences

    What has happened to the idea that only natural forces shaped the Amazon?

    an approach that leaves people out of the equation is no longer tenable

    Question says → Passage says

    • has been shown to be incorrectis no longer tenable
    • by recent researchThe archaeological evidence shows

    Why: 'No longer tenable' means it can't be defended any more, and the archaeological evidence shows people shaped the forest. So recent research has proved the assumption wrong: B.

    The trap: C names Feinsinger, but he's the ecologist who criticises the assumption, not one who made it. A is wrong because ecologists 'have assumed' it, not questioned it.

    Question 25

    Answer: CSection F, third sentence

    What would applying the new view of Amazonia's past do?

    The new understanding of the pre-history of Amazonia, however, points toward a middle ground.

    Question says → Passage says

    • our new insights into the Amazonian pastThe new understanding of the pre-history of Amazonia
    • change present policies on developmentpoints toward a middle ground

    Why: E describes the current situation: some environmentalists oppose all development while destructive development continues. A 'middle ground' between those two means changing current development policy: C.

    The trap: A (allowing no development at all) is the 'extreme position' of some environmentalists in E, which the writer says has hurt the environment. The new understanding moves away from it, not towards it.

    Questions worth a second look

    Question 19

    NO. Ecologists assumed ecosystems were shaped entirely by natural forces and studied areas they believed were untouched by people.

    Question 23

    A. The dismissal of ruins as invaders' leftovers is the view the writer rejects. He says complex indigenous societies lived there for over 1,000 years.

    Question 25

    C. The prehistory points to a middle ground between blocking all development and unchecked destruction, which would change present policy.

    Words from this passage worth keeping

    depleted(A)
    used up, greatly reduced
    epitomize(B)
    be a perfect example of
    luxuriant(B)
    growing thickly and richly
    consequential(C)
    having important results
    unwittingly(C)
    without realising it
    tenable(D)
    able to be defended as reasonable
    apace(E)
    quickly
    judicious(F)
    showing good judgement

    Sit this test on Langujet, then come back

    The full Cambridge 3 Test 3 reading paper: all three passages, 60 minutes, marked the second you finish with a review of every answer. Already done it? Take it again and see if the same traps still get you.

    Take Cambridge 3 Test 3 Reading

    Cambridge IELTS 3, Test 3, Reading Passage 2. The passage and questions belong to Cambridge University Press and are not reproduced here. We quote short extracts only as evidence for our own commentary, and the answers are published for self-marking. Get the book for the full text, or sit the test on Langujet.