Cambridge IELTS 3, Test 4, Reading Passage 3

    Measuring Organisational Performance: reading answers and analysis

    A study of 500 clerks in four identical divisions compared tighter, top-down 'hierarchical' supervision with looser, 'participative' supervision for a year. Both raised productivity (about 25% and 20%), but only through cutting staff. The hierarchical divisions paid for it in loyalty, responsibility and trust, while the participative divisions improved on all of them.

    Questions 28-40 · 13 marks · 3 question blocks

    Answer key and self-check

    Type what you wrote and hit mark. Hide the key first if you haven't done the passage yet. Every question number jumps to its explanation.

    QYour answerAnswer
    Questions 28-30 · Multiple choice
    28
    A
    29
    C
    30
    C
    Questions 31-36 · Summary completion (ONE WORD)
    31
    supervisionAlso accepted: leadership / management
    32
    productivity
    33
    reducedAlso accepted: cut / decreased
    34
    leadershipAlso accepted: group methods of leadership
    35
    overstaffed
    36
    reducedAlso accepted: cut / decreased
    Questions 37-40 · Labelling figures
    37
    C
    38
    D
    39
    G
    40
    F

    Where the answers sit

    The multiple choice (28-30) covers the study's purpose and setup. The summary (31-36) covers the two programmes. The figure labels (37-40) match the results section, in order.

    Multiple choice

    Questions 28-30

    How to attack this block: The study asked whether a manager can boost short-term results by exploiting staff, and at what cost. The divisions were organised identically but differed in past productivity, and they were assigned to programmes at random. Months of planning and training came first.

    Question 28

    Answer: AParagraphs 1 and 2

    What was the experiment set up to find out?

    such short-term increases are obtained only at a substantial and serious cost to the organisation… To what extent will the quality of his organisation suffer if he does so?

    Question says → Passage says

    • establish whetherdesigned to answer these questions
    • increased productivity… at any costan impressive earnings record over a short period… To what extent will the quality of his organisation suffer

    Why: The study was 'designed to answer these questions': how much can a manager boost short-term results, and how much will the organisation suffer? That's asking whether higher productivity is worth any price, which is A.

    The trap: D copies the word 'exploiting' from the question the study asks. But the study investigates what happens if a manager exploits his staff. It wasn't designed to exploit anyone. B mistakes a feature of the set-up (same technology) for its purpose.

    Question 29

    Answer: CParagraph 3

    What was true of all four divisions?

    Each division was organised in exactly the same way, used the same technology, did exactly the same kind of work, and had employees of comparable aptitudes.

    Question says → Passage says

    • identical patterns of organisationorganised in exactly the same way

    Why: 'Organised in exactly the same way' is a direct match for 'identical patterns of organisation': C.

    The trap: D is the clever trap: the divisions were assigned to the two programmes 'on a random basis', but they weren't randomly chosen for the study. A misreads 500 clerks as per division, when it's the total. B is wrong because some divisions were historically high in productivity and some below average.

    Question 30

    Answer: CParagraph 6, second sentence

    What happened before the experiment began?

    Beforehand, several months were devoted to planning, and there was also a training period of approximately six months.

    Question says → Passage says

    • before the experimentBeforehand
    • spent a number of months preparingseveral months were devoted to planning… a training period of approximately six months

    Why: 'Beforehand' signals the time, and months of planning plus about six months of training are the preparation: C.

    The trap: D tempts because attitudes were measured 'just before' the year. But that was about their attitudes to their work, not their feelings about the study. A is the reverse of Paragraph 5: 'No attempt was made' to fit divisions to programmes.

    Summary completion (ONE WORD)

    Questions 31-36

    How to attack this block: The programmes differed in their method of supervision, and productivity was computed weekly. The participative side reduced detailed supervision and trained leaders in group methods. The hierarchical side found the divisions 30% overstaffed and cut staff by 25%. The key accepts synonyms such as cut or decreased.

    Question 31

    Answer: supervisionParagraph 7 and Paragraph 8

    Also accepted: leadership / management

    What was done differently in each programme?

    an attempt was made to change the supervision so that the decision levels were pushed down

    Question says → Passage says

    • a different method ofchange the supervision / modifying the supervision

    Why: Both programmes changed the supervision: looser in the participative divisions, closer in the hierarchical ones. The gap follows 'method of', so you need a noun: 'supervision'. The key also accepts 'leadership' or 'management'.

    The trap: 'Productivity' is what was measured, not what was changed, and it's the answer to the next gap. Don't use one word for both.

    Question 32

    Answer: productivityParagraph 6, third sentence

    What was calculated every week?

    Productivity was measured continuously and computed weekly throughout the year.

    Question says → Passage says

    • calculated on a weekly basiscomputed weekly
    • throughout this timethroughout the year

    Why: 'Computed weekly' becomes 'calculated on a weekly basis'. The thing computed is productivity. One word, a noun.

    The trap: 'Attitudes' were measured too, but only 'just before and after' the year, not every week.

    Question 33

    Answer: reducedParagraph 7, first sentence

    Also accepted: cut / decreased

    What happened to supervision in the participative programme?

    the decision levels were pushed down and detailed supervision of the workers reduced

    Question says → Passage says

    • supervision of all workers wasdetailed supervision of the workers reduced

    Why: The gap follows 'was', so you need a past participle. The passage says supervision of the workers was 'reduced'. 'Cut' and 'decreased' are also accepted.

    The trap: 'More general supervision' comes next, and some students write 'generalised' or 'general'. The summary is mirroring the hierarchical line ('was increased'), so it needs the opposite change: reduced.

    Question 34

    Answer: leadershipParagraph 7, third sentence

    Also accepted: group methods of leadership

    What were supervisors in the participative programme trained in?

    were trained in group methods of leadership, which they endeavoured to use as much as their skill would permit

    Question says → Passage says

    • supervisory staffthe managers, assistant managers, supervisors and assistant supervisors
    • given training inwere trained in

    Why: They were trained in 'group methods of leadership'. With a one-word limit, take the core noun: 'leadership'.

    The trap: Writing the full phrase 'group methods of leadership' breaks the ONE WORD limit. 'Group' alone doesn't make sense as a training subject here.

    Question 35

    Answer: overstaffedParagraph 8, fourth and fifth sentences

    What did timing the jobs reveal about the hierarchical divisions?

    This showed that these divisions were overstaffed by about 30%.

    Question says → Passage says

    • work groups were found to beThis showed that these divisions were
    • by 30%by about 30%

    Why: Timing the jobs showed the divisions had about 30% too many staff. The gap needs an adjective after 'to be': 'overstaffed', one word.

    The trap: Don't mix up the two numbers. 30% is how overstaffed they were, and 25% is how much staff was cut, which is the next gap.

    Question 36

    Answer: reducedParagraph 8, last two sentences

    Also accepted: cut / decreased

    What happened to the hierarchical divisions' workforce?

    The general manager then ordered the managers of these two divisions to cut staff by 25%.

    Question says → Passage says

    • the work force wasstaff
    • by 25%cut staff by 25%

    Why: The staff were cut by 25%. After 'was' you need a past participle: 'cut', 'reduced' or 'decreased' are all accepted.

    The trap: 'Transferred' is in the next sentence, but that's how the cut was done, not what happened to the workforce as a whole. And the passage stresses 'no one was to be dismissed', so 'dismissed' is wrong.

    Labelling figures

    Questions 37-40

    How to attack this block: Each figure is described in order in the results: Figure 1 shows salary cost per unit (changes in productivity), Figure 2 feelings of responsibility for getting work done, Figure 3 managers feeling 'closer', and Figure 4 whether supervisors 'pull' for employees (personal support).

    Question 37

    Answer: CChanges in Productivity, first paragraph

    What does Figure 1 show?

    Figure 1 shows the changes in salary costs per unit of work, which reflect the change in productivity that occurred in the divisions.

    Question says → Passage says

    • Figure 1Figure 1 shows
    • changes in productivityreflect the change in productivity

    Why: Figure 1 plots salary cost per unit of work, and the passage tells you what that stands for: the change in productivity. The label is C.

    The trap: B (cost increases for the company) picks up 'salary costs'. But costs per unit fell as productivity rose, and the passage says what the figure 'reflects'. E (productivity when the supervisor was absent) belongs to the Figure 2 paragraph.

    Question 38

    Answer: DChanges in Attitudes, second paragraph

    What does Figure 2 show?

    Figure 2 shows that when more general supervision and increased participation were provided, the employees' feeling of responsibility to see that the work got done increased.

    Question says → Passage says

    • employees' feelings of responsibilitythe employees' feeling of responsibility
    • towards completion of workto see that the work got done

    Why: The sentence that names Figure 2 is about employees' feeling of responsibility for getting the work done. That's label D almost word for word.

    The trap: E (productivity when the supervisor was absent) is in the same paragraph: clerks kept working when the supervisor was away. That's extra detail after 'Again', not what Figure 2 shows.

    Question 39

    Answer: GChanges in Attitudes, last paragraph, first sentence

    What does Figure 3 show?

    As Figure 3 shows, the employees in the participative programme at the end of the year felt that their manager and assistant manager were 'closer to them'

    Question says → Passage says

    • employees feel closerthe employees… felt that… were 'closer to them'

    Why: Figure 3 is about how close employees felt to their managers by the end of the year. Label G is the one about employees feeling closer.

    The trap: I (supervisors' opinion as to closeness) has the right idea but the wrong point of view. The feeling belongs to the employees, not the supervisors.

    Question 40

    Answer: FChanges in Attitudes, last paragraph, second sentence

    What does Figure 4 show?

    as Figure 4 shows, employees in the participative programme felt that their supervisors were more likely to 'pull' for them, or for the company and them, and not be solely interested in the company

    Question says → Passage says

    • employees' opinionemployees… felt that
    • personal support from managementtheir supervisors were more likely to 'pull' for them

    Why: To 'pull for' someone means to support them. Figure 4 shows whether employees felt their supervisors backed them, or only the company. That's personal support from management: F.

    The trap: A (employees' interest in the company) picks up 'interested in the company', but that's the supervisors' interest, and it's what employees hoped they weren't 'solely' focused on. G (feeling closer) is Figure 3.

    Questions worth a second look

    Question 29

    C. The divisions had identical organisation and technology. They weren't randomly chosen, only randomly assigned to programmes, and each had 500 clerks between them, not 500 each.

    Question 35

    Timing the jobs showed the divisions were 'overstaffed by about 30%', which is the one-word answer.

    Question 40

    F. Figure 4 is whether supervisors 'pull' for employees, or only for the company, which is personal support from management. G (feeling closer) is Figure 3.

    Words from this passage worth keeping

    clear-cut(Paragraph 1)
    definite and easy to see
    exploiting(Paragraph 2)
    using something unfairly for your own benefit
    aptitudes(Paragraph 3)
    natural abilities
    entailed(Paragraph 4)
    involved as a necessary part
    habitual(Paragraph 5)
    usual, done regularly
    endeavoured(Paragraph 7)
    tried hard
    overstaffed(Paragraph 8)
    having more workers than needed
    adverse(Changes in Attitudes)
    harmful, negative

    Sit this test on Langujet, then come back

    The full Cambridge 3 Test 4 reading paper: all three passages, 60 minutes, marked the second you finish with a review of every answer. Already done it? Take it again and see if the same traps still get you.

    Take Cambridge 3 Test 4 Reading

    Cambridge IELTS 3, Test 4, Reading Passage 3. The passage and questions belong to Cambridge University Press and are not reproduced here. We quote short extracts only as evidence for our own commentary, and the answers are published for self-marking. Get the book for the full text, or sit the test on Langujet.