Cambridge IELTS 3, Test 1, Reading Passage 3

    The Scientific Method: reading answers and analysis

    Written for research students, the passage argues (with Medawar and Popper) that science is not inductive. There is no unbiased observation, and research starts from a hypothesis, a guess, which is then tested by deducing and checking predictions. The tidy step-by-step 'scientific method' in published papers describes how research is written up, not how it's actually done.

    Questions 29-40 · 12 marks · 4 question blocks

    Answer key and self-check

    Type what you wrote and hit mark. Hide the key first if you haven't done the passage yet. Every question number jumps to its explanation.

    QYour answerAnswer
    Questions 29-33 · Matching headings (i-x)
    29
    iv
    30
    vii
    31
    iii
    32
    v
    33
    vi
    Questions 34-35 · Multiple choice (choose TWO paragraphs)
    34
    B and F(in either order)
    35
    Questions 36-39 · YES / NO / NOT GIVEN
    36
    YES
    37
    NO
    38
    NOT GIVEN
    39
    YES
    Question 40 · Multiple choice (writer's purpose)
    40
    D

    Where the answers sit

    The headings (29-33) cover C to G. The choose-TWO (34-35) asks which paragraphs address the reader directly. YES / NO / NOT GIVEN (36-39) and question 40 need the whole passage.

    Matching headings (i-x)

    Questions 29-33

    How to attack this block: C explains the inductive myth, D the role of hypotheses (every observation starts from an expectation), and E how hypotheses are tested. F reassures you that anticipating results is normal. G contrasts how research is done with how it's reported (Watson's book versus the DNA papers).

    Question 29

    Answer: ivParagraph C

    Which heading fits Paragraph C?

    The myth of scientific method is that it is inductive: that the formulation of scientific theory starts with the basic, raw evidence of the senses

    Question says → Passage says

    • the inductive methodit is inductive / the starting point of induction
    • explainingstarts with… Out of these sensory data… generalisations will form

    Why: C lays out what induction claims: start with raw observation, collect 'facts', and let a theory grow out of them. It explains the method (and calls it a myth) before the writer knocks it down in D.

    The trap: x (The unbiased researcher) tempts because C mentions 'unbiased, unprejudiced observation'. That's one step in the inductive story, and the 'naive, pure and objective researcher' is mocked in D, not C.

    Question 30

    Answer: viiParagraph D, middle

    Which heading fits Paragraph D?

    All scientific work of an experimental or exploratory nature starts with some expectation about the outcome. This expectation is a hypothesis.

    Question says → Passage says

    • the role of hypothesesHypotheses provide the initiative and incentive for the inquiry and influence the method

    Why: D argues that every piece of research starts from an expectation, a hypothesis, and that this hypothesis decides which observations count, which method is chosen and which experiments run. That's the role hypotheses play.

    The trap: x (The unbiased researcher) matches the last line, 'Where is your naive, pure and objective researcher now?'. But D says that researcher doesn't exist. The heading names a detail, and the wrong way round.

    Question 31

    Answer: iiiParagraph E, first sentence

    Which heading fits Paragraph E?

    having been formulated they can and must be tested rigorously, using the appropriate methodology

    Question says → Passage says

    • the testing of hypothesestested rigorously / some further test shows it not to be correct

    Why: E walks through what happens to a hypothesis once you have one: test it, then drop, change or keep it depending on whether your predictions come true. Testing is the thread through every sentence.

    The trap: viii (Deducing the consequences of hypotheses) is very close because E mentions deducing consequences. But deducing is just the step that gives you predictions to test. The paragraph's real subject is the test.

    Question 32

    Answer: vParagraph F, first sentence

    Which heading fits Paragraph F?

    So don't worry if you have some idea of what your results will tell you before you even begin to collect data

    Question says → Passage says

    • anticipating resultssome idea of what your results will tell you
    • before data is collectedbefore you even begin to collect data

    Why: The heading is almost a paraphrase of the first sentence. The rest of F backs it up: no scientist waits for all the evidence before guessing what it means.

    The trap: ii (Antidotes to bacterial infection) picks up the mould example at the end. That's just an illustration of accidental discovery, a single detail.

    Question 33

    Answer: viParagraph G, last two sentences

    Which heading fits Paragraph G?

    'scientific method' may more usefully be thought of as a way of writing up research rather than as a way of carrying it out

    Question says → Passage says

    • how research is donethe psychological behaviour that brings it about / a way of carrying it out
    • how it is reportedthe final thesis or published papers / a way of writing up research

    Why: G contrasts the messy real process (guesses, corrections, blind alleys) with the neat, logical order of published papers. The conclusion puts it in a sentence: scientific method describes how research is written up, not how it's done.

    The trap: i (The Crick and Watson approach to research) names the example the writer uses. Their papers and Watson's book are there to show the difference between doing and reporting, not to describe their personal approach.

    Multiple choice (choose TWO paragraphs)

    Questions 34-35

    How to attack this block: Look for 'you'. B tells you it's essential to understand the difference so you don't feel you're cheating. F tells you not to worry if you expect certain results.

    Question 34-35

    Answer: B and F (in either order)Paragraph B and Paragraph F

    In which two paragraphs does the writer give the reader direct advice?

    It is essential that you, as an intending researcher, understand the difference… So don't worry if you have some idea of what your results will tell you

    Question says → Passage says

    • advice directly to the readerIt is essential that you / So don't worry

    Why: B speaks straight to 'you, as an intending researcher' and tells you what you must understand so you don't get discouraged. F gives an instruction, 'don't worry', aimed at the same reader. Advice means telling the reader what to do or not do.

    The trap: E is the most tempting wrong letter because it uses 'you' all the way through ('the predictions you make'). But that 'you' just describes how the method works, it doesn't advise. D's question to the reader is rhetorical, not advice.

    YES / NO / NOT GIVEN

    Questions 36-39

    How to attack this block: Popper's view is stated in A (YES). A fulfilled prediction only supports a hypothesis 'until such time' as a test disproves it, so it isn't confirmed as true (NO). The last paragraph says scientific method is better seen as a way of writing up research (YES). The writer never says many people research in a mistaken way.

    Question 36

    Answer: YESParagraph A, second sentence

    Does the writer agree that Popper called the scientific method hypothetico-deductive?

    the position taken by Karl Popper in The Logic of Scientific Discovery (1972, 3rd edition) that the nature of scientific method is hypothetico-deductive

    Question says → Passage says

    • Popper saysthe position taken by Karl Popper

    Why: The writer reports Popper's position directly: scientific method is hypothetico-deductive, not inductive. The statement says the same: YES.

    The trap: The sentence starts with Medawar, so some students think the view isn't Popper's. Medawar was arguing in favour of Popper's position, which makes it Popper's claim.

    Question 37

    Answer: NOParagraph E, third sentence

    Does a correct prediction prove a hypothesis is true?

    If the predictions turn out to be correct then your hypothesis has been supported and may be retained until such time as some further test shows it not to be correct.

    Question says → Passage says

    • the hypothesis is confirmed as trueyour hypothesis has been supported… until such time as some further test shows it not to be correct

    Why: 'Supported' is much weaker than 'confirmed as true', and the writer adds that a later test can still show the hypothesis is wrong. So a fulfilled prediction never proves it true. That contradicts the statement: NO.

    The trap: The first half of the sentence ('predictions turn out to be correct') matches the statement, so it feels like YES. The key is the second half: 'until such time' means the hypothesis is only kept for now.

    Question 38

    Answer: NOT GIVENParagraph B and Paragraph C

    Does the writer say many people do research the wrong way?

    so that you do not become discouraged or begin to suffer from a feeling of 'cheating' or not going about it the right way

    Question says → Passage says

    • research in a mistaken waynot going about it the right way

    Why: The writer says many people believe in the wrong theory of method (induction is 'generally believed' and a myth). He also worries researchers might feel they're doing it wrong. But he never says how many people actually do research wrongly, so it's NOT GIVEN.

    The trap: 'Not going about it the right way' looks like a match, but it's a feeling the writer wants you to avoid, not a claim about how people really work. Believing a myth about research is not the same as doing research badly.

    Question 39

    Answer: YESParagraph G, last sentence

    Is the 'scientific method' more about describing research than doing it?

    'scientific method' may more usefully be thought of as a way of writing up research rather than as a way of carrying it out

    Question says → Passage says

    • a way of describing researcha way of writing up research
    • a way of doing ita way of carrying it out

    Why: 'Writing up' becomes 'describing', and 'carrying it out' becomes 'doing'. The statement is the writer's conclusion in other words: YES.

    The trap: The hedge 'may more usefully be thought of' makes some students choose NOT GIVEN. But the writer is clearly stating his own view, and the statement keeps the comparison ('more… than'), so it matches.

    Multiple choice (writer's purpose)

    Question 40

    How to attack this block: The passage speaks to 'you, as an intending researcher' and explains two conceptions of research so you don't lose heart. Cheating and guesswork appear only as details.

    Question 40

    Answer: DParagraph B (and the whole passage)

    What is the writer mainly trying to do in the passage?

    It is essential that you, as an intending researcher, understand the difference between these two interpretations of the research process

    Question says → Passage says

    • to help Ph.D studentsyou, as an intending researcher… so that you do not become discouraged
    • different conceptions of the research processthese two interpretations of the research process

    Why: B states the purpose: to help you understand two interpretations of research (inductive vs hypothetico-deductive) so you don't lose heart. Every later paragraph explains one of these views or reassures you, which matches D.

    The trap: C (explain the logic of the research paper) uses the last paragraph, where papers are written in a logical order, but that's one point at the end. A takes 'cheating' from B, which is about feeling like a cheat, not being told not to cheat. B takes 'guesswork and inspiration' from E, where it's a description, not encouragement.

    Questions worth a second look

    Question 37

    NO. A correct prediction means the hypothesis is supported and kept only until a later test shows it wrong, so it's never confirmed as true.

    Question 38

    NOT GIVEN. The writer calls induction a myth but never claims many researchers work the wrong way.

    Question 33

    vi. G contrasts the tidy published papers with the messy real process (Watson's book about DNA). The Crick and Watson heading is only an example inside it.

    Words from this passage worth keeping

    inspirational(A)
    coming from sudden creative ideas
    discouraged(B)
    having lost confidence or enthusiasm
    unprejudiced(C)
    not influenced by earlier opinions
    rigorously(E)
    very carefully and thoroughly
    retained(E)
    kept
    holistic(G)
    involving the whole process together, not separate steps
    blind alleys(G)
    approaches that lead nowhere
    writing up(G)
    producing the formal written report of research

    Sit this test on Langujet, then come back

    The full Cambridge 3 Test 1 reading paper: all three passages, 60 minutes, marked the second you finish with a review of every answer. Already done it? Take it again and see if the same traps still get you.

    Take Cambridge 3 Test 1 Reading

    Cambridge IELTS 3, Test 1, Reading Passage 3. The passage and questions belong to Cambridge University Press and are not reproduced here. We quote short extracts only as evidence for our own commentary, and the answers are published for self-marking. Get the book for the full text, or sit the test on Langujet.