Cambridge IELTS 2, Test 1, Reading Passage 3

    Children's Thinking: reading answers and analysis

    The Kendlers tested children on a two-step machine (press a button for a marble, then use the marble to get a toy) and concluded they couldn't reason deductively. Cole found African adults also failed, but they succeeded with familiar objects (match-boxes and a key). Hewson made the machine less mysterious and five-year-olds' success jumped from 30% to 90%.

    Questions 28-40 · 13 marks · 2 question blocks

    Answer key and self-check

    Type what you wrote and hit mark. Hide the key first if you haven't done the passage yet. Every question number jumps to its explanation.

    QYour answerAnswer
    Questions 28-35 · Classification (which researcher)
    28
    A
    29
    C
    30
    C
    31
    D
    32
    D
    33
    C
    34
    B
    35
    D
    Questions 36-40 · YES / NO / NOT GIVEN
    36
    NOT GIVEN
    37
    YES
    38
    YES
    39
    YES
    40
    NO

    Where the answers sit

    The researcher classification (28-35) needs the whole passage, and Cole and Hewson are the answer three times each. YES / NO / NOT GIVEN (36-40) runs from the Kendlers to Hewson's results.

    Classification (which researcher)

    Questions 28-35

    How to attack this block: Hull is the 'eminent' psychologist. Cole showed that adults struggle too, used match-boxes instead of marbles, and chose familiar objects. Hewson changed the apparatus (drawers, the marble-swapping game) and showed the earlier conclusions were wrong. The book's key gives the college-student comparison to the Kendlers, because it was in their experiments that college students were tested.

    Question 28

    Answer: AParagraph 1

    Which researcher is described as a big name in psychology?

    One of the most eminent of psychologists, Clark Hull, claimed that the essence of reasoning lies in the putting together of two 'behaviour segments'

    Question says → Passage says

    • famous in the field of psychologyOne of the most eminent of psychologists

    Why: 'Eminent' means famous and respected, and the passage uses it about Hull in the very first sentence. Nobody else gets a description of their reputation.

    The trap: Hewson's work is called 'of great interest' in paragraph 6, but that praises the research, not the person's fame.

    Question 29

    Answer: CParagraph 4

    Who showed that some adults also struggle with the button-and-marble task?

    from another psychologist, Michael Cole, and his colleagues, that adults in an African culture apparently cannot do the Kendlers' task either

    Question says → Passage says

    • certain adultsadults in an African culture
    • as well as childreneither
    • the two-stage experimentthe Kendlers' task

    Why: 'The Kendlers' task' is the button-and-marble machine, and Cole found adults in an African culture couldn't do it 'either', meaning just like the children. That's problems for certain adults as well as children.

    The trap: The Kendlers (B) designed the task, and college students appear in their experiments, but those adults succeeded. It was Cole who showed adults failing.

    Question 30

    Answer: CParagraph 5, first sentence

    Who tested deductive reasoning with no marbles at all?

    Instead of the button-pressing machine, Cole used a locked box and two differently coloured match-boxes, one of which contained a key that would open the box.

    Question says → Passage says

    • without the use of any marblesInstead of the button-pressing machine… a locked box and two differently coloured match-boxes

    Why: Cole's version swaps the whole machine for a locked box, match-boxes and a key. The two stages are the same, but there's no marble anywhere.

    The trap: Hewson (D) also changed the apparatus, but he kept the marbles: the second stage still has the child pop a marble in the hole, and he even played a marble 'swapping game'.

    Question 31

    Answer: DParagraph 9

    Who seems to have shown that changing the equipment made some age groups do much better?

    The two modifications together produced a jump in success rates from 30 per cent to 90 per cent for five-year- olds and from 35 per cent to 72.5 per cent for four-year-olds.

    Question says → Passage says

    • a change in the apparatusThe two modifications
    • dramatically improves the performancea jump in success rates
    • children of certain agesfive-year- olds… four-year-olds

    Why: The 'two modifications' are Hewson's drawers and swapping game, and they tripled the five-year-olds' success rate. 'Certain ages' matters: it worked for four- and five-year-olds but not three-year-olds, and the statement is careful to allow for that.

    The trap: Cole (C) also changed the apparatus and made the task easier, but his subjects were adults, not children.

    Question 32

    Answer: DParagraph 7, second sentence

    Who swapped the buttons for drawers?

    he replaced the button-pressing mechanism in the side panels by drawers in these panels which the child could open and shut

    Question says → Passage says

    • replaced button-pressingreplaced the button-pressing mechanism
    • with drawer-openingby drawers in these panels which the child could open and shut

    Why: This is a near word-for-word match with Hewson's first 'crucial change'. The drawers took the mystery out of the first stage.

    The trap: Cole (C) also got rid of the button-pressing machine, but he used match-boxes and a locked box, not a machine with drawers. Don't be thrown by 'inductive' in the statement: the passage talks about deductive reasoning, and the drawer detail is what decides it.

    Question 33

    Answer: CParagraph 5

    Who used everyday objects instead of a machine?

    Now the subject is dealing not with a strange machine but with familiar meaningful objects; and it is clear to him what he is meant to do.

    Question says → Passage says

    • things… encountered in everyday lifefamiliar meaningful objects / two differently coloured match-boxes
    • rather than with a machinenot with a strange machine

    Why: Match-boxes, a key and a locked box are things the African adults would know from daily life. The passage spells out the contrast: familiar objects, not a strange machine. That's Cole.

    The trap: Hewson (D) also made the task less strange, but his subjects still used a machine, just with drawers instead of buttons.

    Question 34

    Answer: BParagraph 6, last sentence

    Who tested both five-year-olds and college students on the same equipment?

    five-year-old children solve the problem as well as college students did in the Kendlers' own experiments

    Question says → Passage says

    • college studentscollege students did in the Kendlers' own experiments
    • using the same apparatusthe Kendler apparatus

    Why: The college students were tested 'in the Kendlers' own experiments', on the Kendlers' machine, the same machine their child subjects used. The key words are 'the same apparatus with both sets': only the Kendlers tested children and college students on one unchanged machine.

    The trap: Hewson (D) is the obvious pick, because his five-year-olds are the ones compared with the college students. But his children used a modified machine with drawers, so it isn't the same apparatus.

    Question 35

    Answer: DParagraph 6 and the last paragraph

    Whose work suggests earlier conclusions about children's reasoning were wrong?

    the difficulty lies not in the inferential processes which the task demands, but in certain perplexing features of the apparatus and the procedure

    Question says → Passage says

    • earlier experimentsthe Kendlers concluded that they were incapable of deductive reasoning
    • may have led to the wrong conclusionsthis difficulty cannot be taken as proof that they are incapable of deductive reasoning

    Why: The Kendlers concluded children can't reason deductively. Hewson's work shows the problem was the confusing machine, not the reasoning, and the writer's conclusion follows from it. 'Is cited as having demonstrated' fits: the writer brings in Hewson's work as proof.

    The trap: Cole (C) also weakens the Kendlers' case, but his study was about adults. The statement is about children's ability, which is Hewson's area.

    YES / NO / NOT GIVEN

    Questions 36-40

    How to attack this block: The Kendlers trained each stage separately but not the link between them (YES), and Cole showed that apparatus and procedure matter (YES). The book's key reads Hewson's swapping game as using equivalent same-size marbles (YES). Three-year-olds didn't improve, so not all ages benefited (NO). Being Hull's followers doesn't mean they studied under him (NOT GIVEN).

    Question 36

    Answer: NOT GIVENParagraph 2, first sentence

    Were the Kendlers Hull's students?

    Two followers of Clark Hull, Howard and Tracey Kendler, devised a test for children that was explicitly based on Clark Hull's principles.

    Question says → Passage says

    • (link to Hull)Two followers of Clark Hull / explicitly based on Clark Hull's principles

    Why: 'Followers' means they agreed with and built on Hull's ideas. It doesn't tell you whether they ever studied under him. You can follow a thinker you've never met, so the passage gives no answer.

    The trap: It's tempting to read 'followers' as 'students' and say YES. But it doesn't contradict the statement either, so NO is wrong too. The relationship simply isn't described.

    Question 37

    Answer: YESParagraphs 2 and 3

    Did the Kendlers train each stage on its own but not how to link them?

    The children were trained on each stage separately… But they did not for the most part 'integrate', to use the Kendlers' terminology.

    Question says → Passage says

    • trained… separately in the two stagesThe children were trained on each stage separately
    • not in how to integrateproceed without further help

    Why: The training covered each stage, and the test was whether children could join them 'without further help'. Integration was the thing being tested, so it can't have been taught. Both halves of the statement match.

    The trap: Some students mark NOT GIVEN because the passage never says 'they were not trained to integrate'. But 'without further help' shows the linking step was left for the children to work out.

    Question 38

    Answer: YESParagraphs 4 and 5

    Did Cole show that how well adults do depends on the equipment and method?

    a task was devised which was strictly analogous to the Kendlers' one but much easier for the African males to handle… It then turns out that the difficulty of 'integration' is greatly reduced

    Question says → Passage says

    • adult performancethe African males
    • depends on features of the apparatusstrictly analogous… but much easier / psychologically it is quite different

    Why: Cole kept the logic of the task the same and changed only the objects. The adults who failed with the machine succeeded with match-boxes and a key. So their performance depended on the apparatus, which is the YES.

    The trap: The phrase 'features of the apparatus and the procedure' comes from the Hewson paragraph, so some students say NO because it's about children. Cole's result shows the same thing for adults. The statement's 'inductive' is the question writer's word; don't let it push you to NO.

    Question 39

    Answer: YESParagraph 8

    Did all of Hewson's experiments use marbles of one size?

    How is he to know that any other marble of similar size will do just as well?… Hewson made the functional equivalence of different marbles clear by playing a 'swapping game'

    Question says → Passage says

    • marbles of the same sizeany other marble of similar size
    • (marbles are interchangeable)the functional equivalence of different marbles

    Why: The published key says YES. The reasoning: the child has to see that one marble is as good as another of similar size, and Hewson's swapping game shows the marbles are interchangeable, so the marbles in his set-up were equivalent in size.

    The trap: Many students choose NOT GIVEN here, and with good reason: the passage says 'similar size', not 'same size', and never says 'all' his experiments. We think the key is questionable on this one, but in the published key it's YES.

    Question 40

    Answer: NOParagraph 9, last sentence

    Did Hewson's changes help children of every age?

    For three-year- olds, for reasons that are still in need of clarification, no improvement — rather a slight drop in performance - resulted from the change.

    Question says → Passage says

    • a higher success ratea jump in success rates
    • for children of all agesFor three-year- olds… no improvement

    Why: Four- and five-year-olds improved, but three-year-olds didn't, and actually did slightly worse. One age group going down is enough to contradict 'all ages', so NO.

    The trap: The big jumps in the first sentence of the paragraph make YES feel right. Read on: the three-year-old result is in the next sentence.

    Questions worth a second look

    Question 40

    NO. Three-year-olds showed no improvement, even a slight drop, so the success rate didn't rise for all ages.

    Question 36

    NOT GIVEN. The Kendlers are called 'followers' of Hull, which doesn't mean they studied under him.

    Question 34

    B (the Kendlers) in the official key. The college-student results come from 'the Kendlers' own experiments', which is why Hewson isn't the answer.

    Words from this passage worth keeping

    eminent(Paragraph 1)
    famous and highly respected in a field
    novel(Paragraph 1)
    new and different
    devised(Paragraph 2)
    planned or invented
    deductive reasoning(Paragraph 3)
    working out a conclusion step by step from what you know
    analogous(Paragraph 4)
    similar in structure, so comparable
    inferential(Paragraph 6)
    to do with drawing conclusions from evidence
    perplexing(Paragraph 6)
    confusing and hard to understand
    functional equivalence(Paragraph 8)
    doing the same job, so one can replace the other

    Sit this test on Langujet, then come back

    The full Cambridge 2 Test 1 reading paper: all three passages, 60 minutes, marked the second you finish with a review of every answer. Already done it? Take it again and see if the same traps still get you.

    Take Cambridge 2 Test 1 Reading

    Cambridge IELTS 2, Test 1, Reading Passage 3. The passage and questions belong to Cambridge University Press and are not reproduced here. We quote short extracts only as evidence for our own commentary, and the answers are published for self-marking. Get the book for the full text, or sit the test on Langujet.