Cambridge IELTS 15, Test 3, Reading Passage 3

    Why fairy tales are really scary tales: reading answers and analysis

    Anthropologist Jamie Tehrani borrowed biologists' 'phylogenetic analysis' to trace 58 related versions of Little Red Riding Hood. Plot events changed as freely as characters, and cautionary messages weren't especially stable. What survived best was the gruesome, frightening detail. Jack Zipes thinks stories last only if they matter, while Mathias Clasen sees scary tales as a safe way to practise fear.

    Questions 27-40 · 14 marks · 3 question blocks

    Answer key and self-check

    Type what you wrote and hit mark. Hide the key first if you haven't done the passage yet. Every question number jumps to its explanation.

    QYour answerAnswer
    Questions 27-31 · Sentence endings (A-F)
    27
    C
    28
    B
    29
    F
    30
    A
    31
    E
    Questions 32-36 · Summary completion (word list A-I)
    32
    D
    33
    F
    34
    B
    35
    C
    36
    G
    Questions 37-40 · Multiple choice
    37
    B
    38
    D
    39
    A
    40
    A

    Where the answers sit

    The sentence endings (27-31) cover the first four paragraphs. The summary (32-36) covers Tehrani's method and findings. The multiple choice (37-40) runs from the method to Clasen at the end.

    Sentence endings (A-F)

    Questions 27-31

    How to attack this block: Plot details vary around the world (the wolf eats the grandmother or locks her up). Tehrani rejects the idea that survival lessons are why the tales last. Academics have built theories despite a 'huge gap' in knowledge, so without factual basis. Biology's methods give insights, and all 58 stories came from oral traditions.

    Question 27

    Answer: CParagraph 1

    What is true of plot details in fairy tales?

    the same story often takes a variety of forms in different parts of the world… In some versions, the wolf swallows up the grandmother, while in others it locks her in a cupboard.

    Question says → Passage says

    • show considerable global variationtakes a variety of forms in different parts of the world
    • details of the plotthe wolf swallows up the grandmother… locks her in a cupboard

    Why: The first paragraph is all about versions: the wolf eats the grandmother or locks her up, the girl escapes alone or is rescued. Those are plot details, and they vary 'in different parts of the world'. Ending C.

    The trap: Ending D (animals that become humans) borrows from the wolf dressing in the grandmother's clothes. But that's a disguise, not a transformation, and the passage never says all tales contain it.

    Question 28

    Answer: BParagraph 2, first three sentences

    What idea about the life lessons in fairy tales does Tehrani reject?

    The universal appeal of these tales is frequently attributed to the idea that they contain cautionary messages… But his research suggests otherwise.

    Question says → Passage says

    • the useful lessons for lifecautionary messages / survival-relevant information
    • are the reason for their survivalThe universal appeal of these tales is frequently attributed to
    • Tehrani rejectshis research suggests otherwise

    Why: The common view is that tales last because of their warnings, such as not talking to strangers. 'His research suggests otherwise' is Tehrani rejecting that. Later his analysis shows the cautionary parts change as freely as trivial details. Ending B.

    The trap: Ending F (no factual basis) also sounds like rejecting theories, and it's the right ending for question 29. But question 28 is about the lessons themselves, and only B describes what those lessons are claimed to do.

    Question 29

    Answer: FParagraph 2, second half

    What does the writer say about theories on why fairy tales matter to society?

    'We have this huge gap in our knowledge about the history and prehistory of storytelling… That hasn't stopped anthropologists, folklorists and other academics devising theories

    Question says → Passage says

    • Various theoriesdevising theories
    • the social significance of fairy talesthe importance of fairy tales in human society
    • without factual basisthis huge gap in our knowledge

    Why: Academics came up with theories even though there's a 'huge gap' in what we know about storytelling's history. Theories built across a gap in knowledge have no facts underneath them. Ending F.

    The trap: Ending A (biological methods) comes in the very next sentence, but that's about Tehrani's new way of testing the theories, not about how the theories were made.

    Question 30

    Answer: AParagraph 2, last sentence, and Paragraph 3

    Where can insights into how fairy tales developed come from?

    Now Tehrani has found a way to test these ideas, borrowing a technique from evolutionary biologists.

    Question says → Passage says

    • methods used in biological researcha technique from evolutionary biologists / phylogenetic analysis
    • the development of fairy talesto discover how they have evolved

    Why: Tehrani borrows phylogenetic analysis, a biologists' method, 'to discover how they have evolved'. Evolution is development, so biology's methods provide the insights. Ending A.

    The trap: Ending C (global variation) is about plot details, not about where insights come from. 'May be provided through' needs a source or method, and only A gives one.

    Question 31

    Answer: EParagraph 4, second sentence

    What do all the tales Tehrani analysed have in common?

    he ended up with 58 stories recorded from oral traditions

    Question says → Passage says

    • All the fairy tales analysed by Tehrani58 stories
    • originally spoken rather than writtenrecorded from oral traditions

    Why: 'Oral' means spoken. The stories were written down later ('recorded'), but they came from oral traditions, so they were spoken first. Ending E.

    The trap: 'Recorded' might make you think they were written originally. It means collected and written down, and 'from oral traditions' tells you the source was spoken.

    Summary completion (word list A-I)

    Questions 32-36

    How to attack this block: Tehrani first checked whether links existed among the stories, then which aspects had the fewest variations. Events changed as freely as characters. Warning elements were no more stable than trivial details, and horror survived best. 'Plot' and 'people' are near-synonym traps.

    Question 32

    Answer: DParagraph 4, last sentence

    What did Tehrani first check existed among the 58 stories?

    Once his phylogenetic analysis had established that they were indeed related

    Question says → Passage says

    • find out if ___ existedhad established that
    • among 58 storiesthey were indeed related

    Why: His first step was to confirm the stories 'were indeed related'. If stories are related, there are links between them. 'Links' (D).

    The trap: 'Records' (E) echoes 'recorded from oral traditions' in the sentence before, but that's how the stories were collected, not what he was testing for.

    Question 33

    Answer: FParagraph 5, first sentence

    Which aspects did he look for that had the fewest of what?

    First he tested some assumptions about which aspects of the story alter least as it evolves, indicating their importance.

    Question says → Passage says

    • which aspectswhich aspects of the story
    • had fewest ___alter least
    • would be the most important onesindicating their importance

    Why: If an aspect 'alters least', it has the fewest changes, or 'variations' (F). The second half matches too: 'indicating their importance' = 'would be the most important ones'.

    The trap: 'Events' (B) is tempting because folklorists think events change least. But the gap is the measure being counted, not the aspect. 'Fewest events' would mean something else entirely.

    Question 34

    Answer: BParagraphs 5 and 6

    Contrary to other beliefs, what did Tehrani find tended to change over time?

    Folklorists believe that what happens in a story is more central to the story than the characters… However, Tehrani found no significant difference in the rate of evolution of incidents compared with that of characters.

    Question says → Passage says

    • Contrary to other beliefsFolklorists believe… However
    • some ___ that were included in a storyCertain episodes are very stable… but there are lots of other details that can evolve quite freely
    • eventsincidents / what happens in a story

    Why: Folklorists believed events were the stable core. Tehrani found incidents evolved just as fast as characters, so events changed too. Incidents = 'events' (B), and the plural fits 'some ___ that were'.

    The trap: 'People' (H) is tempting since characters changed as well, but nobody believed characters were stable, so that isn't 'contrary to other beliefs'. 'Plot' (I) is close in meaning but doesn't work after 'some… that were'.

    Question 35

    Answer: CParagraph 7

    Which parts of a story did Tehrani find surprisingly unimportant?

    But the really big surprise came when he looked at the cautionary elements of the story… Yet in his analysis such elements were just as flexible as seemingly trivial details.

    Question says → Passage says

    • was also surprisedthe really big surprise
    • some sort of ___the cautionary elements / the possible dangers that may be faced there
    • were unimportantjust as flexible as seemingly trivial details

    Why: 'Cautionary' means giving a warning. These parts changed as freely as trivial details, which shows they weren't important to the story's survival. 'Warning' (C).

    The trap: 'Horror' (G) is the opposite: it's what survived best. Don't mix up the parts that changed with the parts that lasted.

    Question 36

    Answer: GParagraph 8, first sentence

    What mattered most for a story's survival?

    The answer, it would appear, is fear - blood-thirsty and gruesome aspects of the story, such as the eating of the grandmother by the wolf, turned out to be the best preserved of all.

    Question says → Passage says

    • most important in a story's survivalthe best preserved of all
    • horrorfear / blood-thirsty and gruesome aspects

    Why: Gruesome, frightening detail was 'the best preserved of all', so fear is what keeps a story alive. The box word for fear and gruesomeness is 'horror' (G).

    The trap: 'Ending' (A) might come to mind because the wolf being cut open happens near the end, but Tehrani found the middle no more important than the beginning or end. It's the frightening content that matters, not its position.

    Multiple choice

    Questions 37-40

    How to attack this block: Tehrani compared many versions of one basic story. Zipes says gruesome details won't last unless they matter. Tehrani cites Chinese and Japanese versions, where the villain is a woman, to show Zipes' women-as-victims theory doesn't hold everywhere. Clasen sees scary stories as a safe way to learn fear.

    Question 37

    Answer: BParagraphs 3 and 4

    How did Tehrani test his ideas?

    Tehrani has used the same approach to compare related versions of fairy tales to discover how they have evolved

    Question says → Passage says

    • many different forms of the same basic storyrelated versions of fairy tales / Little Red Riding Hood in its many forms
    • looked atcompare

    Why: He took one tale, Little Red Riding Hood, collected 58 related versions and compared them. That's many forms of the same basic story. B.

    The trap: D is the main trap: he borrowed biologists' method, but he used it on stories. He didn't compare stories with living creatures. C is wrong because the stories were confirmed as related, and A because all 58 came from oral traditions.

    Question 38

    Answer: DParagraph 9, second sentence

    What is Jack Zipes' view when he responds to Tehrani?

    'Even if they're gruesome, they won't stick unless they matter,' he says.

    Question says → Passage says

    • features of stories only survivethey won't stick unless
    • if they have a deeper significancethey matter

    Why: 'Won't stick' means won't survive, and 'unless they matter' is 'only if they have a deeper significance'. For Zipes, the deeper significance is women as victims. D.

    The trap: C sounds like a fair summary of disagreeing with Tehrani, but Zipes doesn't say violence is overrated. He accepts gruesome detail exists and says it isn't enough on its own. A: women as victims is Zipes' own theme, but he never says Tehrani ignores changes in women's roles.

    Question 39

    Answer: AParagraph 9, last two sentences

    Why does Tehrani mention the Chinese and Japanese versions?

    But Tehrani points out that although this is often the case in Western versions, it is not always true elsewhere. In Chinese and Japanese versions, often known as The Tiger Grandmother, the villain is a woman

    Question says → Passage says

    • Jack Zipes' theorythe perennial theme of women as victims
    • is incorrectit is not always true elsewhere

    Why: Zipes says the tales last because women are victims. In the Chinese and Japanese versions the woman is the villain, not the victim, so his theory doesn't hold everywhere. A.

    The trap: D is the reverse: the examples count against Zipes, not for him. 'But' at the start of the sentence signals disagreement.

    Question 40

    Answer: AParagraph 10, last sentence

    What does Clasen believe scary tales do for us?

    scary stories teach us what it feels like to be afraid without having to experience real danger, and so build up resistance to negative emotions

    Question says → Passage says

    • a safe waywithout having to experience real danger
    • learning to deal with fearteach us what it feels like to be afraid… build up resistance to negative emotions

    Why: We feel fear but face no real danger, which is safe, and we build up resistance, which is learning to deal with it. A.

    The trap: C borrows 'Habits and morals change', but Clasen's point is that what scares us stays 'constant', so tales don't reflect changing values. B is the opposite of his view that we 'seek out' scary entertainment.

    Questions worth a second look

    Question 29

    F. Theories were devised despite a 'huge gap in our knowledge' of storytelling's history, so they lack a factual basis.

    Question 37

    B, not D. Tehrani used a biological method on many versions of one tale. He didn't compare stories with living creatures.

    Question 34

    B (events). He found incidents evolved just as fast as characters, contradicting the folklorists' belief that events are the stable core.

    Words from this passage worth keeping

    disposes of(Paragraph 1)
    gets rid of; here, kills
    cautionary(Paragraph 2)
    giving a warning
    attributed to(Paragraph 2)
    said to be caused by
    devising(Paragraph 2)
    inventing or planning
    trivial(Paragraph 7)
    small and unimportant
    gruesome(Paragraph 8)
    horrible, involving death or injury
    gripping(Paragraph 8)
    so exciting that it holds your attention
    perennial(Paragraph 9)
    lasting a long time or constantly recurring

    Sit this test on Langujet, then come back

    The full Cambridge 15 Test 3 reading paper: all three passages, 60 minutes, marked the second you finish with a review of every answer. Already done it? Take it again and see if the same traps still get you.

    Take Cambridge 15 Test 3 Reading

    Cambridge IELTS 15, Test 3, Reading Passage 3. The passage and questions belong to Cambridge University Press and are not reproduced here. We quote short extracts only as evidence for our own commentary, and the answers are published for self-marking. Get the book for the full text, or sit the test on Langujet.