Cambridge IELTS 19, Test 4, Reading Passage 2

    Deep-sea mining: reading answers and analysis

    A microbe from a deep-sea sponge may yield a new antibiotic, and scientists fear such finds will be lost in the rush to mine the seabed for nickel, cobalt and rare earths. Mining firms promise better ore with little waste. Lawyers and ecologists warn that the deep sea is barely mapped, rules don't exist yet, and hydrothermal vents in particular must be left alone.

    Questions 14-26 · 13 marks · 3 question blocks

    Answer key and self-check

    Type what you wrote and hit mark. Hide the key first if you haven't done the passage yet. Every question number jumps to its explanation.

    QYour answerAnswer
    Questions 14-17 · Matching information (paragraphs A-F)
    14
    C
    15
    F
    16
    E
    17
    D
    Questions 18-23 · Matching statements to people
    18
    D
    19
    B
    20
    A
    21
    E
    22
    B
    23
    C
    Questions 24-26 · Summary completion (ONE WORD ONLY)
    24
    waste
    25
    machinery
    26
    caution

    Where the answers sit

    Paragraph matching (14-17) uses C, D, E and F once each. The people matching (18-23) needs the whole passage, with the Blue Ocean Law paper (B) used twice. The summary (24-26) sits in C and the first line of D.

    Matching information (paragraphs A-F)

    Questions 14-17

    How to attack this block: Each item is a single detail. Cobalt for electric car batteries is C. The 'around 70%' of the planet covered by ocean is F. Vents formed where seawater meets magma is E. The missing global rulebook is D.

    Question 14

    Answer: CParagraph C, second sentence

    Which paragraph mentions fast-growing demand for one material used in transport?

    demand for resources such as copper, aluminium, cobalt for electric car batteries and other metals to power technology and smartphones, is soaring

    Question says → Passage says

    • the rapidly increasing needdemand… is soaring
    • one raw material in the transport industrycobalt for electric car batteries

    Why: 'Soaring' demand is 'rapidly increasing need', and the one metal tied to transport is cobalt, used in electric car batteries. The other metals are for technology and smartphones.

    The trap: Paragraph F mentions 'society's rising needs', which also sounds like increasing demand, but no specific material or transport link is given there.

    Question 15

    Answer: FParagraph F, first sentence

    Which paragraph gives an approximate figure for how much of the Earth is ocean?

    The oceans occupy around 70% of the planet and are relatively unexplored

    Question says → Passage says

    • a rough estimatearound 70%
    • the area of the Earth covered by the oceansThe oceans occupy… of the planet

    Why: 'Around' signals a rough estimate, and '70% of the planet' is the area covered. 'Occupy' = 'cover'.

    The trap: Paragraph C says the deep sea holds more metals 'than all land reserves combined'. That compares resources, not area, so it isn't the estimate you need.

    Question 16

    Answer: EParagraph E, first two sentences

    Which paragraph explains how an underwater habitat full of both minerals and animals forms?

    hydrothermal vents, which are created when seawater meets volcanic magma… The mineral-rich vents and their surrounds are also home to many well-known animals

    Question says → Passage says

    • how… is formedwhich are created when seawater meets volcanic magma
    • where minerals and organisms co-existThe mineral-rich vents… are also home to many well-known animals

    Why: E explains that vents are created when seawater meets magma, then says the mineral-rich vents are home to many animals. That covers formation, minerals and organisms together.

    The trap: Paragraph F also talks about vents (Tunnicliffe wants them off-limits), but it never explains how they form.

    Question 17

    Answer: DParagraph D, first sentence

    Which paragraph says the world has no agreed rules yet for seabed exploration?

    the global regulatory framework is not yet drafted

    Question says → Passage says

    • the countries of the worldglobal
    • have yet to agree on rulesregulatory framework is not yet drafted

    Why: A regulatory framework is a set of rules, and 'not yet drafted' means they haven't been written or agreed. 'Global' covers all countries.

    The trap: Paragraph F has Tunnicliffe calling for 'strict controls', which sounds like rules, but she's saying what should happen, not that the rules don't exist yet.

    Matching statements to people

    Questions 18-23

    How to attack this block: B appears twice, because the paper both accuses miners of ignoring local communities and says Moon, Mars and Venus are better mapped than the deep sea. Johnston is the only pro-mining voice, so the 'move away from land reserves' view is his. Tunnicliffe's 'greatest assault' and Copley's 'no mining on vents' are easy to swap, so check the wording.

    Question 18

    Answer: DParagraph F, first sentence

    Who thinks it's sensible to stop relying on heavily mined land reserves?

    instead of continually looking at the fast depleting land resources of the planet to meet society's rising needs

    Question says → Passage says

    • A move away frominstead of continually looking at
    • heavily mined reserves on landthe fast depleting land resources
    • is a good ideaIt makes sense

    Why: Johnston says it makes sense to explore the oceans instead of land resources that are running out fast. 'Makes sense' = 'a good idea', and 'fast depleting' implies heavy mining.

    The trap: Upton (A) also talks about a 'better way' of using the deep sea, but he's comparing medicine with mining at sea, not sea with land.

    Question 19

    Answer: BParagraph D, second sentence

    Who says the harm to local areas and people is being ignored?

    a general disregard for environmental and social impacts, and the marginalisation of indigenous peoples and their rights

    Question says → Passage says

    • are being ignoreda general disregard for
    • negative effects… on local areas and their inhabitantsenvironmental and social impacts… indigenous peoples

    Why: The paper by Hunter, Aguon and Singh says deep-sea mining, like past resource rushes, shows 'disregard' for environmental and social impacts and pushes aside indigenous peoples. Disregard = ignoring.

    The trap: Tunnicliffe (E) warns of huge damage too, but she talks about ecosystems, not communities, and doesn't say the harm is ignored.

    Question 20

    Answer: AParagraph B, first half

    Who thinks the sea has more valuable things to offer than minerals?

    to see if there are any more medicines or drugs down there before we destroy it for ever… this could be a better way of exploiting the economic potential of the deep sea

    Question says → Passage says

    • more worthwhile things to extractmore medicines or drugs / a better way of exploiting the economic potential
    • than mineralsthe rush to exploit the deep sea's equally rich metal and mineral resources

    Why: Upton searches the deep sea for medicines and says this 'could be a better way' of using its economic potential than mining. Better than minerals = more worthwhile.

    The trap: Tunnicliffe (E) mentions 'biotechnology spin-offs' from vents, which sounds similar, but her point is protecting vents, not comparing the value of what can be extracted.

    Question 21

    Answer: EParagraph F, near the end

    Who says deep-sea mining will damage sea life more than anything humans have done before?

    'Mining will be the greatest assault on deep-sea ecosystems ever inflicted by humans,' according to hydrothermal vent expert Verena Tunnicliffe

    Question says → Passage says

    • No other… will have such a destructive impactthe greatest assault… ever inflicted by humans
    • marine lifedeep-sea ecosystems

    Why: 'The greatest assault ever' means nothing else will be as destructive. 'Ecosystems' = 'marine life'.

    The trap: The paper in paragraph E says mining 'poses a grave threat', but that's serious, not 'greatest ever'. And it isn't one of the listed people.

    Question 22

    Answer: BParagraph D, last sentence

    Who says we know more about space than the deep ocean?

    The surface of the Moon, Mars and even Venus have all been mapped and studied in much greater detail

    Question says → Passage says

    • outer spacethe Moon, Mars and even Venus
    • More is knownmapped and studied in much greater detail

    Why: The same three authors say the Moon, Mars and Venus have been studied in much more detail than the deep seabed. That's more knowledge about space. B is used twice, which is allowed.

    The trap: Johnston (D) says the oceans are 'relatively unexplored', which is close, but he makes no comparison with space.

    Question 23

    Answer: CParagraph E, last sentence

    Who says experts agree there's one habitat that shouldn't be mined?

    'On deep-sea vents, scientists are clear,' says Dr Jon Copley of the National Oceanography Centre, Southampton: 'we don't want mining on them.'

    Question says → Passage says

    • one marine life habitatdeep-sea vents
    • experts agreescientists are clear
    • mining should not take placewe don't want mining on them

    Why: Copley speaks for scientists in general ('scientists are clear') about one habitat, vents, and says they don't want mining there. That's expert agreement.

    The trap: Tunnicliffe (E) also says active vents must be off-limits, but that's her own argument. Only Copley says scientists as a group agree.

    Summary completion (ONE WORD ONLY)

    Questions 24-26

    How to attack this block: The first two gaps come from C: what mining supposedly produces little of, and what gets converted from land mining. The last gap is the first thing environmental and legal groups call for at the start of D.

    Question 24

    Answer: wasteParagraph C, third sentence

    What do mining companies say deep-sea mining would produce little of?

    They say that deep-sea mining could yield far superior ore to land mining with little, if any, waste.

    Question says → Passage says

    • superior to those found in the earthfar superior ore to land mining
    • without producing muchwith little, if any

    Why: 'Little, if any' = 'not much'. The noun it goes with is 'waste', which fills the gap after 'producing much'.

    The trap: 'Ore' is in the same sentence, but it's what they want to produce. The summary has already covered it with 'mineral resources'.

    Question 25

    Answer: machineryParagraph C, fourth sentence

    What land equipment is adapted to mine the sea floor?

    most involve employing some form of converted machinery previously used in terrestrial mining

    Question says → Passage says

    • adaptingconverted
    • that has already been used to work on landpreviously used in terrestrial mining

    Why: 'Converted' = 'adapted', and 'terrestrial' means on land. The gap after 'the' needs an uncountable noun ('has already been used'), so 'machinery', not 'machines'.

    The trap: Paragraph F mentions 'giant mining machines', which is plural and would clash with 'has'. Use the word from C: 'machinery'.

    Question 26

    Answer: cautionParagraph D, first sentence

    What do concerned groups think is needed because of possible unknown effects?

    environmental and legal groups have urged caution, arguing there are potentially massive and unknown ramifications

    Question says → Passage says

    • concerned groups strongly believeenvironmental and legal groups have urged
    • unidentified consequencesunknown ramifications

    Why: To 'urge caution' is to say strongly that caution is needed. 'Unknown ramifications' = 'unidentified consequences'. The gap needs a noun: 'caution'.

    The trap: 'Halt' appears in paragraph B (scientists urging a halt to mining), but that's Upton and other scientists, not the environmental and legal groups, and the summary follows paragraph D.

    Questions worth a second look

    Question 20

    A (Upton). He argues that looking for medicines is a better use of the deep sea than mining, which is 'more worthwhile things to extract than minerals'.

    Question 23

    C (Copley). Tunnicliffe also wants vents off-limits, but only Copley says scientists are clear, meaning experts agree.

    Question 25

    Write 'machinery', not 'machines'. The passage talks about converted machinery previously used in land mining.

    Words from this passage worth keeping

    pathogenic(A)
    causing disease
    prospecting(A)
    searching an area for something valuable
    weigh up(B)
    consider carefully before deciding
    terrestrial(C)
    on or relating to land
    ramifications(D)
    consequences, often unexpected ones
    marginalisation(D)
    pushing a group to the edge of society so it has little power
    untapped(F)
    not yet used
    depleting(F)
    running out or being used up

    Sit this test on Langujet, then come back

    The full Cambridge 19 Test 4 reading paper: all three passages, 60 minutes, marked the second you finish with a review of every answer. Already done it? Take it again and see if the same traps still get you.

    Take Cambridge 19 Test 4 Reading

    Cambridge IELTS 19, Test 4, Reading Passage 2. The passage and questions belong to Cambridge University Press and are not reproduced here. We quote short extracts only as evidence for our own commentary, and the answers are published for self-marking. Get the book for the full text, or sit the test on Langujet.