Women applying for management jobs succeed more often than men (one in four shortlisted, against one in six), probably because the few who apply are better qualified and prepare more thoroughly. The number of women non-executive directors has doubled, but is still tiny. Delayering has hurt women's progress, while demographics, education and networks help, and employers must value the difference.
The paragraph matching (14-19) uses six of the seven paragraphs, one each. The consultant matching (20-23) covers B, D, E and G. The short answers (24-27) run from D to G.
Matching information (paragraphs A-G)
Questions 14-19
How to attack this block: A gives the success rates, and C compares how men and women apply. D shows women directors doubling, and E covers delayering holding women back. F gives the reasons more women are working (demographics, education), and G the support networks.
Question 14
Answer: EParagraph E
Which paragraph covers the downside of the way companies are being restructured?
Sears said that this has halted progress for women in as much as de-layering has taken place either where women are working or in layers they aspire to.
Question says → Passage says
current company restructuring patternsa recent feature of corporate life in the recession has been the de-layering of management structures
drawbackshas halted progress for women
Why: 'De-layering of management structures' is restructuring, and it's 'recent', so current. The drawback is that it has stopped women's progress. E.
The trap: G talks about 'barriers' for women, which sounds like drawbacks, but those are about recruitment and attitudes, not company structure.
Question 15
Answer: GParagraph G, first sentence
Which paragraph mentions organisations that support professional women?
Organisations such as the European Women's Management Development Network provide a range of opportunities for women to enhance their skills and contacts.
Question says → Passage says
AssociationsOrganisations such as the European Women's Management Development Network
provide supportprovide a range of opportunities for women to enhance their skills and contacts
Why: G names a network for women managers and lists what it offers: skills, contacts, workshops and conferences. That's support from an association. G.
The trap: Paragraph B has NB Selection, and D has Korn/Ferry, but those are consultancies doing surveys, not support organisations for women.
Question 16
Answer: AParagraph A
Which paragraph gives the success rate for women applying for management jobs?
while one in six men who appear on interview shortlists get jobs, the figure rises to one in four for women
Question says → Passage says
female job applicants for management positionsWomen who apply for jobs in middle or senior management
The success ratehave a higher success rate than men / one in four for women
Why: A states the key finding and gives the numbers: one in four women on shortlists get the job, against one in six men. A.
The trap: B also says women are 'more successful than men', but B's own content is the survey's salary range and sectors (the example answer) and Marx's comments. The success rate itself is in A.
Question 17
Answer: CParagraph C, second half
Which paragraph compares how men and women go about applying for jobs?
Women tend to research thoroughly before applying for positions or attending interviews. Men, on the other hand, seem to rely on their ability to sell themselves
Question says → Passage says
Male and femaleWomen… Men, on the other hand
approaches to job applicationsmore selective and conservative in their job search / rely on their ability to sell themselves
Why: 'On the other hand' is your contrast signal. Women research and are selective, while men rely on selling themselves. C.
The trap: B also compares men and women (fewer women apply), but that's about numbers of applicants, not how they apply.
Question 18
Answer: FParagraph F
Which paragraph explains why more women are being employed?
Demographic trends suggest that the number of women going into employment is steadily increasing.
Question says → Passage says
more women are being employedthe number of women going into employment is steadily increasing
Reasonsa number of factors encouraging / Demographic trends / a far greater number of women are now passing through higher education
Why: F lists the factors behind more women at work: population trends and more women in higher education. F.
The trap: D shows women's numbers on boards doubling. That's an improvement in numbers, not reasons for it, and it's about directors, not employment in general.
Question 19
Answer: DParagraph D, second sentence
Which paragraph shows more women now on company boards?
This year the survey shows a doubling of the number of women serving as non-executive directors compared with the previous year.
Question says → Passage says
The improvement in female numbersa doubling of the number of women
company management structuresboards of directors / non-executive directors
Why: Boards of directors are part of company management, and the number of women on them has doubled. That's an improvement in numbers: D.
The trap: D also says progress is 'painfully slow' (only 18 out of 354), but an improvement is still an improvement. Don't let the negative tone throw you off.
Matching points to consultants
Questions 20-23
How to attack this block: Sears makes two points: more women starting their own businesses, and women in higher grades than before. Marx notes that far fewer women than men apply for senior posts. Antal says there are still many hurdles to getting shortlisted, so selection doesn't favour women.
Question 20
Answer: CParagraph G, second half
Which consultant says the selection process doesn't favour women?
still so hard for women to even get on to shortlists - there are so many hurdles and barriers
Question says → Passage says
Selection proceduresget on to shortlists
do not favour womenso hard for women / so many hurdles and barriers
Why: If it's 'so hard' for women even to be shortlisted, the selection process is working against them. That's Antal: C.
The trap: Marx (A) reports that shortlisted women succeed more often, which might suggest selection favours women. But she explains it by women being better qualified, and she never says the procedures don't favour them.
Question 21
Answer: BParagraph E, last sentence
Which consultant says more women are running their own businesses?
Sears also noted a positive trend from the recession, which has been the growing number of women who have started up on their own
Question says → Passage says
female-run businesseswomen who have started up on their own
is increasingthe growing number
Why: 'Started up on their own' means set up their own businesses, and the number is 'growing'. That's Hilary Sears: B.
The trap: 'Started up on their own' doesn't contain the word 'business', so it's easy to miss. Read it as the idiom it is.
Question 22
Answer: AParagraph B, last sentence
Which consultant says more men than women apply for top jobs?
We should not lose sight of the fact that significantly fewer women apply for senior positions in comparison with men.
Question says → Passage says
Male applicants exceed female applicantssignificantly fewer women apply… in comparison with men
top postssenior positions
Why: If fewer women apply, more men do. Marx says this directly: A.
The trap: Paragraph A also says 'far fewer of them apply', but that's the writer reporting the survey. The question asks which consultant makes the point, and Marx is the one quoted saying it.
Question 23
Answer: BParagraph D, last sentence
Which consultant says women now hold higher positions than before?
Women have raised the level of grades we are employed in but we have still not broken through barriers to the top.
Question says → Passage says
hold higher positions nowraised the level of grades we are employed in
than they used tohave raised
Why: 'Raised the level of grades' means women are now employed at higher levels. Sears (B) says it, while adding that the very top is still closed. That's her second answer.
The trap: The 'but we have still not broken through' part may put you off, but the statement only says positions are higher than before, not that women reach the top.
Short answers (NO MORE THAN THREE WORDS)
Questions 24-27
How to attack this block: Women non-executive directors doubled, delayering disadvantaged women, demographic trends show more women working, and employers must change their attitude. Both spellings of delayering are accepted.
Question 24
Answer: doubledParagraph D, second sentence
Also accepted: it has doubled / double / doubling / a doubling
How has the number of women in top management changed, according to the annual survey?
This year the survey shows a doubling of the number of women serving as non-executive directors compared with the previous year.
Question says → Passage says
the annual surveythe annual survey of boards of directors
What changea doubling
Why: The change is that the number doubled. 'Doubled', 'it has doubled', 'a doubling' and 'double' are all accepted.
The trap: '18 posts' or 'painfully slow' come from the next sentence. They describe the current level and the pace, not the change.
Question 25
Answer: de-layeringParagraph E
Also accepted: delayering
Which feature of company structure has held women back?
a recent feature of corporate life in the recession has been the de-layering of management structures. Sears said that this has halted progress for women
Question says → Passage says
company structuringmanagement structures
disadvantaged womenhalted progress for women
Why: De-layering (removing levels of management) is the structural change that has halted women's progress. Spell it with or without the hyphen; both are accepted.
The trap: 'The recession' is the background, not an aspect of company structure. The question asks about structuring, and de-layering is the structural change.
Question 26
Answer: demographic trendsParagraph F, second sentence
What evidence shows more women are working now?
Demographic trends suggest that the number of women going into employment is steadily increasing.
Question says → Passage says
What information tells usDemographic trends suggest
more women are working nowadaysthe number of women going into employment is steadily increasing
Why: 'Suggest' tells you this is the evidence. Demographic trends (two words) are the information showing the rise.
The trap: 'Higher education' is the next sentence, but it explains why women are better qualified, not how we know more women are working.
Question 27
Answer: employersParagraph G, last sentence
Who needs to change their attitude to recruitment?
Until there is a belief among employers, until they value the difference, nothing will change.
Question says → Passage says
change their attitudeUntil there is a belief among… until they value the difference
Why: Antal says nothing will change until employers value the difference women bring. They're the group whose attitude must change: 'employers'.
The trap: Women themselves are discussed throughout, and 'organisations' appear in G, but Antal points specifically at employers.
C (Antal). 'It's still so hard for women to even get on to shortlists'. Marx's success rates don't show the procedures favour women, only that the few who apply do well.
D. The directors survey shows women's numbers doubling, which is the improvement. F explains why more women are in the workforce generally.
Words from this passage worth keeping
shortlists(A)
the small group of candidates chosen for interview
counterparts(C)
people in an equivalent position
shortcomings(C)
weaknesses or faults
aspire to(E)
hope to reach a higher position
de-layering(E)
removing levels of management from a company
demographic(F)
relating to population statistics
anecdotal(G)
based on personal stories rather than research
hurdles(G)
difficulties or obstacles to overcome
Sit this test on Langujet, then come back
The full Cambridge 1 Test 4 reading paper: all three passages, 60 minutes, marked the second you finish with a review of every answer. Already done it? Take it again and see if the same traps still get you.
Cambridge IELTS 1, Test 4, Reading Passage 2. The passage and questions belong to Cambridge University Press and are not reproduced here. We quote short extracts only as evidence for our own commentary, and the answers are published for self-marking. Get the book for the full text, or sit the test on Langujet.