Cambridge IELTS 2, Test 4, Reading Passage 2

    Pictures and Learning to Read: reading answers and analysis

    The writer blames falling literacy on picture books. Illustrations have grown while text has shrunk, pictures stop children forming their own mental images, and older students struggle with text-only books, even at Oxford and Cambridge. Studies by Dale Willows and Jay Samuels found pictures slow reading, mislead readers, and reduce the words children learn.

    Questions 14-26 · 13 marks · 4 question blocks

    Answer key and self-check

    Type what you wrote and hit mark. Hide the key first if you haven't done the passage yet. Every question number jumps to its explanation.

    QYour answerAnswer
    Questions 14-17 · Multiple choice
    14
    D
    15
    B
    16
    D
    17
    C
    Questions 18-21 · YES / NO / NOT GIVEN
    18
    NO
    19
    YES
    20
    YES
    21
    NOT GIVEN
    Questions 22-25 · Matching information (paragraphs A-J)
    22
    F
    23
    C
    24
    J
    25
    I
    Question 26 · Multiple choice (best title)
    26
    C

    Where the answers sit

    The multiple choice (14-17) covers D, I, F and J. YES / NO / NOT GIVEN (18-21) covers B, D and F. The paragraph matching (22-25) needs C, F, I and J. Question 26 is about the whole passage.

    Multiple choice

    Questions 14-17

    How to attack this block: 'Barking at text' means reading aloud without understanding. Willows found pictures slow reading. The universities are worried about a rapid decline in undergraduate literacy. Children who ignore pictures and look at the words learn more.

    Question 14

    Answer: DParagraph D, second sentence

    What does 'barking at text' mean?

    Even if a child is able to read aloud fluently, he or she may not be able to understand much of it: this is called 'barking at text'.

    Question says → Passage says

    • have difficulty assessing its meaningmay not be able to understand much of it

    Why: The definition comes just before the phrase: the child reads the words aloud fine but doesn't understand them. That's a problem with meaning, D.

    The trap: A (too loudly) plays on the word 'bark', but the passage says they read 'fluently', with no mention of volume. C (imagination) is the writer's worry in paragraph E, not this definition.

    Question 15

    Answer: BParagraph I, first sentence

    What does the passage suggest about pictures?

    pictures affected speed and accuracy and the closer the pictures were to the words, the slower and more inaccurate the child's reading became

    Question says → Passage says

    • slow down reading progressthe slower and more inaccurate the child's reading became

    Why: Willows found that pictures made children read more slowly and less accurately. That's pictures slowing down reading, B.

    The trap: A (less detailed) picks up on B's complaint that illustrations are 'increasingly detailed and obtrusive'. But the writer doesn't want simpler pictures; the argument is against pictures in reading books altogether.

    Question 16

    Answer: DParagraph F, last sentence

    Why are the university academics worried?

    The Universities of Oxford and Cambridge recently held joint conferences to discuss the noticeably rapid decline in literacy among their undergraduates.

    Question says → Passage says

    • University academics are concernedThe Universities of Oxford and Cambridge recently held joint conferences
    • a significant change in student literacythe noticeably rapid decline in literacy among their undergraduates

    Why: The conferences were about a 'noticeably rapid decline' in undergraduates' literacy. A rapid decline is a significant change, D.

    The trap: B (can't understand academic texts) sounds like a result of poor literacy, but the passage doesn't say it. Neither A nor C is mentioned at all.

    Question 17

    Answer: CParagraph J, last sentence

    What helps the youngest readers develop good skills quickly?

    those who seemed to ignore the pictures and pointed at the words learnt more words than the children who pointed at the pictures

    Question says → Passage says

    • ignore pictures in the textseemed to ignore the pictures and pointed at the words
    • quickly develop good reading skillslearnt more words

    Why: Among children given pictures, those who ignored them learnt more words. So being encouraged to ignore pictures is the option the research supports, C.

    The trap: D (telling stories) twists paragraph G, which says children should listen to stories read well, not learn to tell them. A is the opposite of the writer's whole argument.

    YES / NO / NOT GIVEN

    Questions 18-21

    How to attack this block: The accepted tradition is to use pictures (NO to 'few pictures'). Teachers aim at recognition and meaning (YES), and older children turn away from books without pictures (YES). The conferences' effect on literacy isn't reported.

    Question 18

    Answer: NOParagraph B, second sentence

    Is it traditional to give children books with few pictures?

    When teachers use picture books, they are simply continuing a long-established tradition that is accepted without question.

    Question says → Passage says

    • traditionally accepteda long-established tradition that is accepted without question
    • few picturespicture books

    Why: The tradition is to use picture books, the opposite of 'few pictures'. The statement reverses the passage, so NO.

    The trap: The writer clearly wants fewer pictures, so you might think 'few pictures' is the accepted view. The writer's opinion goes against the tradition, not with it.

    Question 19

    Answer: YESParagraph D, first sentence

    Do teachers try to teach both recognising words and understanding them?

    A teacher's main concern is to help young beginner readers to develop not only the ability to recognise words, but the skills necessary to understand what these words mean.

    Question says → Passage says

    • Teachers aim to teachA teacher's main concern is to help
    • both word recognition and word meaningnot only the ability to recognise words, but… understand what these words mean

    Why: 'Not only… but' gives you both parts: recognising words and understanding them. That matches 'both' in the statement. YES.

    Question 20

    Answer: YESParagraph F, first two sentences

    Do older children struggle with books that have no pictures?

    As they grow older, many children turn aside from books without pictures

    Question says → Passage says

    • Older readersAs they grow older
    • difficulty in adjusting to texts without picturesturn aside from books without pictures / It is hard to wean children off picture books

    Why: Older children turn away from books without pictures, and it's 'hard to wean' them off picture books. Both show difficulty adjusting, so YES.

    The trap: 'Turn aside from' could sound like a choice rather than a difficulty, so some students say NOT GIVEN. The next sentence makes it clear it's hard for them to move on.

    Question 21

    Answer: NOT GIVENParagraph F, last sentence

    Did the academic conferences improve literacy?

    The Universities of Oxford and Cambridge recently held joint conferences to discuss the noticeably rapid decline in literacy among their undergraduates.

    Question says → Passage says

    • recent academic conferencesrecently held joint conferences

    Why: The conferences were held to discuss the decline. The passage says nothing about what happened afterwards, so you can't tell whether literacy improved. NOT GIVEN.

    The trap: Some students say NO because the passage is all about decline. But the decline is why the conferences were held; there's no information on any result.

    Matching information (paragraphs A-J)

    Questions 22-25

    How to attack this block: F shows the decline in every age and ability group, and C says current practice goes against the research. J has the children who ignored pictures learning more, and I has pictures misleading readers about a word's meaning.

    Question 22

    Answer: FParagraph F

    Which paragraph shows the decline affects all ages and abilities?

    The least intelligent are most vulnerable, but tests show that even intelligent children are being affected.

    Question says → Passage says

    • differing abilitiesThe least intelligent… even intelligent children
    • differing agesAs they grow older… even at senior levels… their undergraduates

    Why: F covers the range: weaker and brighter children, older children, senior levels and university undergraduates. That's differing ages and abilities in one paragraph.

    The trap: A mentions 16-year-olds with a reading age of 14, but that's one age group and no range of abilities.

    Question 23

    Answer: CParagraph C

    Which paragraph says current reading methods ignore the research?

    a great deal of empirical evidence shows that pictures interfere in a damaging way with all aspects of learning to read. Despite this

    Question says → Passage says

    • research findingsempirical evidence
    • go againstDespite this
    • Reading methods currently in usethe first books that many school children receive are totally without text

    Why: C sets the evidence (pictures damage reading) against practice (first books with no text at all). 'Despite this' is the signal that practice goes against the research.

    The trap: H introduces the research experiments, so it looks like a fit. But H only says the experiments exist; it doesn't contrast them with what schools do.

    Question 24

    Answer: JParagraph J, last sentence

    Which paragraph says children who ignore pictures do better?

    those who seemed to ignore the pictures and pointed at the words learnt more words than the children who pointed at the pictures

    Question says → Passage says

    • Readers able to ignore picturesthose who seemed to ignore the pictures
    • make greater progresslearnt more words

    Why: Samuels' study compared children who pointed at words with children who pointed at pictures. The word-pointers learnt more, which is greater progress.

    The trap: I is also research on pictures, but Willows looks at speed, accuracy and misleading clues, not at children who ignore the pictures.

    Question 25

    Answer: IParagraph I, last sentence

    Which paragraph says pictures can mislead readers about what a word means?

    they may well be misled by aspects of the pictures which are not closely related to the meaning of the word they are trying to understand

    Question says → Passage says

    • Illustrationsthe pictures
    • misleading information about word meaningmisled… not closely related to the meaning of the word

    Why: Willows says that a child who looks to a picture for help with an unknown word may pick up the wrong clue. That's misleading information about meaning.

    The trap: J is the other research paragraph, but it measures how many words children learn, not whether pictures give the wrong meaning.

    Multiple choice (best title)

    Question 26

    How to attack this block: Every paragraph builds the case that pictures damage learning to read. Decline and research are parts of that argument, not its topic.

    Question 26

    Answer: CWhole passage

    Which title best sums up the whole passage?

    a great deal of empirical evidence shows that pictures interfere in a damaging way with all aspects of learning to read

    Question says → Passage says

    • The harminterfere in a damaging way / how detrimental pictures are for beginner readers
    • picture bookspicture books

    Why: Every paragraph adds to one argument: pictures harm children learning to read. The decline in literacy is the problem, and the research is the evidence, but the topic is the harm. C.

    The trap: A (global decline in reading levels) fits only paragraph A and parts of F. D (research) fits only H to J, and that research is about reading books, not children's literature in general.

    Questions worth a second look

    Question 17

    C. Children who ignored the pictures and pointed at the words learned more than those who looked at pictures, though still fewer than those shown no pictures at all.

    Question 18

    NO. Teachers using picture books are following a long-established tradition, so pictures, not their absence, are what's traditionally accepted.

    Question 22

    F. The least intelligent are most vulnerable, even intelligent children are affected, and it reaches undergraduates, so every age and ability is covered.

    Words from this passage worth keeping

    impedes(A)
    slows down or blocks
    obtrusive(B)
    too noticeable, in an unwelcome way
    impoverished(B)
    made poorer and weaker
    empirical(C)
    based on experiments and observation
    adverse(D)
    harmful or negative
    redundant(E)
    not needed any more
    innate(E)
    something you're born with
    detrimental(H)
    causing harm or damage

    Sit this test on Langujet, then come back

    The full Cambridge 2 Test 4 reading paper: all three passages, 60 minutes, marked the second you finish with a review of every answer. Already done it? Take it again and see if the same traps still get you.

    Take Cambridge 2 Test 4 Reading

    Cambridge IELTS 2, Test 4, Reading Passage 2. The passage and questions belong to Cambridge University Press and are not reproduced here. We quote short extracts only as evidence for our own commentary, and the answers are published for self-marking. Get the book for the full text, or sit the test on Langujet.